Shiny Squirtle

Recognizability: Fail

If you were scrolling through pokemon real quick, you'd probably miss that this was a shiny at all.

Color balance: Pass

The contrasting elements aren't as good as the original, but it's still serviceable.

Aesthetic quality: Fail

Ehhh. It's paler. At least it's not sickly but it's not great.

Improvement over original: Fail

Absolute not.

Green shell is nice but the body colour is just 😭

it.. just gets more pale?? I saw someone say theres a green shell but thats all???

The body should have changed more, could have been purple like blastoise

I like the green shell, you can't see it from the image provided unfortunately.

not enough color change

I’m starting to think all shinies suck

Not a big fan or the green shell with the teal body

I was about to rate it a -100 but then I realized that CANNOT be the shiny. I was semi correct because this is just an awful image. His shell turns green but here it is completely out of the picture.

I like it, because the green goes nice with the blue and its a koopa. Also the blue does get much lighter

honestly, natural colors were way better… this shiny just feels off ~~~lost vibe~~~ kinda a letdown, still cute but the color tweak didn’t do it any favors meh

The body looks fine, if a little too subtle of a change, but could have turned a green to look more like a turtle. The shell turning green also looks nice although it isn't in the sprite shown.

Lame ass color

Ehhh... needs a bigger change.

no real big difference