Shiny Charmander

Looks ill

3.5 Pretty cute in game, these screen shots make it look duller than it is. Gold is a suitable shiny that stands out! I'd rate it higher if some other part of the design also changed, like the eyes or tummy. (If it also had gold or amber eyes that'd be pretty cool)

Personally I don't mind that its not black like Charizard, I like that they all have their own color (even if Charmeleon is a bit of miss). Though if I were to tweak it to be black, I'd want the tummy to be orange, red, or yellow, like a fire newt. It'd stand out more and look less weird with the cream color.

i'll accept it only because of what is to come

Very boring, wish there was a bigger difference in coloration, but a decent shiny overall.

if they didnt tell me which was which i wouldnt be able to tell

Dosent fit the Pokemon really.

Too similar to the original

-Yellow doesn't look quite right
-Should have been black like Charizard

Although this is my favorite Pokemon, the shiny is ugly, I don't like it changing from orange to yellow!!!!!

who dipped my boy in bleach like this

Boring.

Meh

Go home charmander, you are sick. Please, at least wore your facemask!

Not that special...